In-store or mail-in service
TAG · PSA · BGSCard Grading Services
Your cards matter to you, so we treat them that way. We've graded nearly 10,000 cards this year, and that experience shows in how carefully we handle every submission, from the moment it arrives to the day it's back in your hands.
As a collector-owned shop, we know what it feels like to send something you care about off to someone else. That's why we keep the process transparent and simple, with real people to talk to if you ever have questions. Whether it's your first submission or your fiftieth, your cards are in good hands with us.
How to submit your cards
-
01
Open Our submission portal
Go to our submission portal and input all your information — this helps us process your submission faster and ensures the correct turnaround tier. You will also receive a submission number, along with a print-out PDF to either bring in-store or ship to us.
-
02
Sleeve & protect your cards
Place each card in a clear penny sleeve, then into a card saver. Package everything securely before shipping.
-
03
Ship to us or drop off in-store
Ship via USPS, FedEx, UPS, or any carrier — or drop off in person at our store.
-
04
We submit your cards, and send you an invoice
Payment is collected once we receive your cards. An invoice will be sent by email. Once paid, your cards are submitted to the respective grading company under the tier you selected.
-
05
Track your submission
Click the link titled "Track My Order" to see the status of your submission. You'll need the provided submission number given to you VIA email, and the correlating last name that you inputted on your order.
-
06
Estimated Turnaround time
Average turnaround time depends on the submission tier of your card(s). However please keep in mind that these are estimates, and not guarantees.
Please refer to the table below - time frames will correlate to the service you choose.
Note on return shipping: You're responsible for all return shipping costs. This is not included in the grading fee. Once your graded cards arrive back at our store, we'll email you a link to pay for return shipping (If applies to your order). An upcharge may apply for certain grading services, so we'll notify you immediately if this happens.
Frequently asked questions
Reach out if you have any other questions! E-Mail: grading@pokemalltcg.com
What is grading and why should I grade my cards?
Card grading involves submitting collectibles to an accredited third-party service—such as PSA—to verify authenticity, assess condition, and encapsulate each card in a protective slab.
For sellers, third-party authentication builds buyer trust and allows top-condition cards to command a significant market premium. For personal collectors, grading provides long-term physical preservation while enhancing the overall presentation of prized cards.
How do these grading companies score my card?
Third-party grading services evaluate cards based on four primary criteria:
- Surface: Absence of scratches, print lines, creases, or other physical blemishes on both sides.
- Edges: Minimal whitening, chipping, or perimeter wear.
- Corners: Sharpness, structural integrity, and lack of impact damage.
- Centering: Horizontal and vertical symmetry of the artwork and borders.
A card's overall grade reflects its cumulative condition across these categories. While our team is happy to provide a preliminary pre-grading evaluation, please note that we cannot guarantee third-party sub-grades or final scores.
How long will it take to get my graded cards back?
Dependent on the grading service - and the tier chosen, timeframes are just an estimate.
UPDATE :There are many delays across the board with a high demand of grading between all service tiers.
TAG Grading Tiers
| Service | Price / Card | Card Year | Insurance | Time Frame |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| TAG Basic (No TAG Score) | $34.99 | 1998+ | Up to $299 | 35 - 45+ Days |
| TAG Standard (TAG Score) | $49.99 | 1998+ | Up to $499 | 35 - 45+ Days |
| TAG Express | $84.99 | 1998+ | Up to $999 | 10 - 15+ Days |
| TAG Priority (360 Video) | $149.99 | 1998+ | Up to $2,499 | 5 - 10+ Days |
| TAG Walk-Through | $299.99 | 1998+ | Up to $4,999 | 2 - 5+ Days |
PSA Grading Tiers
| Service | Price / Card | Card Year | Insurance | Time Frame |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bulk (Paused) | $27.99 | 1980+ | Up to $199 | 120 - 180+ Days |
| Value (Paused) | $37.99 | 1980+ | Up to $499 | 90 - 120+ Days |
| Value Plus (Paused) | $54.99 | 1980+ | Up to $999 | 75 - 90+ Days |
| Regular | $94.99 | 1980+ | Up to $1,099 | 50 - 60+ Days |
| Express | $174.99 | 1980+ | Up to $1,499 | 30 - 45+ Days |
| Super Express | $399.99 | 1980+ | Up to $2,499 | 15 - 20+ Days |
BGS GRADING TIERS
| Service | Price / Card | Card Year | Insurance | Time Frame |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base (Subgrades) (Paused) | $27.49 | 1998+ | Up to $299 | 75+ Days |
| Standard (Paused) | $44.99 | 1998+ | Up to $499 | 45+ Days |
| Express | $89.99 | 1998+ | Up to $999 | 15 - 30+ Days |
| Priority | $174.99 | 1998+ | Up to $1,499 | 5 - 15+ Days |
PokeMall TCG is not liable for the turnaround time of any grading service, for how your card(s) are handled while in the possession of the respective grading company, or for the grade your card(s) ultimately receive.
If PSA (or another grading company) flags your card(s) for a correction fee, PokeMall TCG will send you an invoice. You'll have 5 business days to pay it; if it isn't paid or the fee is declined within that window, your card(s) will be returned ungraded and the grading fee already paid is forfeited.
Grading companies may also reject cards for reasons outside our control. In that case, your card(s) will be returned ungraded and the grading fee is forfeited. PokeMall TCG does not offer refunds on submission services under any circumstances.
Shipping to us. PokeMall TCG is not responsible for cards lost or damaged in transit on their way to us. We are not liable for any such loss or damage, and we are unable to assist in resolving it.
Return shipping from the grading company. If the grading company's shipment back to us is lost or damaged in transit, PokeMall TCG will act on your behalf to help resolve the matter with the grading company.
Shipping back to you. Once your graded cards are returned to us, all outbound shipments are insured for the full fair market value (FMV) of their contents and require a signature upon delivery. In the rare event a package is lost or stolen despite these safeguards, we will assist in filing a claim with the shipping carrier. PokeMall TCG remains not liable for such loss or theft, and any compensation would come solely from the carrier, not from us.
Thank you for considering PokeMall TCG for your grading submission needs!